FIREinTh
Crazy Mango
Posts: 85
Likes: 47
|
Post by FIREinTh on Oct 29, 2018 18:51:30 GMT 7
I haven't been through many drawdowns, so I did some research about how to deal with the recent drop in the markets.
I found a lot posts and articles about August, 2011. I'm sure many of you remember that, and for me it's interesting to read what people were saying back then. That time was different and markets were entering a new era.
The S&P500 dropped about 20% in two weeks in August 2011, but by February 2012 it had fully recovered and it kept going up until April. And we all know the S&P500 has continued to reach new highs since then, with 2013 being an especially good year.
Lesson learned - don't let market drops and the media scare you no matter what they say. It's easy to digest that when the market is going up, but it's a totally different story when you live through a drop yourself with lots invested.
Any stories about how you made it through market drops without panicking and selling?
|
|
|
Post by rgs2001uk on Oct 29, 2018 21:35:11 GMT 7
Been there done that, stock market crashes, currency crashes and exchange rate crashes, I have lost a shitload in the last couple of weeks, funnily enough, my nett is now back to what is was in april.
The UK FTSE has never risen above what it was at its high back in dec 1999, well it has, but it keeps being driven back to the 7000 level, I blame automation and chartists.
Sell everything and buy tulips and magic beans.
|
|
|
Post by Fletchsmile on Nov 1, 2018 16:22:17 GMT 7
First crash/ significant drawdown I really experienced was 1987. The action I took was just ride it out and wait for recovery. Perhaps I was a little stunned and not entirely sure what to do, but removing chunks of money from the market after the horse has bolted didn't seem a sensible strategy. So don't panic probably became my first strategy. Also if you can't afford to ride out the loss you probably shouldn't be invested in the first place. I've never sold out after a crash. I may reevaluate investments and switch allocations, but the metaphor of shutting the door after the horse has bolted does stick with me. So re-evaluate what you have became a subsequent strategy for me. Don't just focus on what has been lost, focus on going forward does it still make sense, and think about recovery potential as well as knock on losses that could still follow. The more significant drawdowns/ crashes I go thru the more I look at them as opportunities to add money to the market. A more adventurous strategy. Adding money when you're working is easier. When you're no longer working/ retired then adding money to take advantage of opportunities is more difficult. Sure you could keep a reserve just in case to add money on weakness. But then you have to ask why that money isn't just invested in the first place as you can't easily time the market and crashes. If you already have enough reserves to ride out the drawdowns, isn't it inefficient to hold extra reserves to add in a crash? Particularly of you favour a "time in the market" instead of "timing the market" strategy. One strategy to address this that I have in mind, but not yet had an opportunity to test, is using secured lending to borrow more after a crash. I've put in place USD and SGD loan facilities that I may consider drawing on after the next crash. I do think about just using them anyway and often feel tempted, but 1) don't really want to leverage up before a crash and increase risk 2) they may also provide additional buffers to ride out storms. So I think of these more of keeping some powder dry, or at least having an agreement to borrow some bullets So I think the more of these drawdowns/crashes you go thru, the more comfortable you are and the more your strategies evolve. Particularly as to looking to the opportunity.
In addition they're also learning opportunities on several levels
|
|
siampolee
Detective
Alive alive O
Posts: 14,172
Likes: 8,986
|
Post by siampolee on Nov 1, 2018 18:17:49 GMT 7
The trustees of my/our family trust use the same tactics, frightened me to death as I had images of the farm and the business concerns etc being sacrificed as an aftermath action on a financial altar of offerings.
They made a killing and have done so yet again on other occasions, fire clearance sale buying spree is worth the risk.
|
|
FIREinTh
Crazy Mango
Posts: 85
Likes: 47
|
Post by FIREinTh on Nov 1, 2018 19:30:55 GMT 7
Thanks for sharing your stories. It's really worthwhile for a relative newbie like myself to hear stories from veterans who have been through multiple crashes.
Definitely an interesting scenario about keeping something in reserve to put in during a crash vs. being fully invested. I met someone who has stayed out of the market since 2008 since he's so worried about another crash that is supposed to happen every year for the past 10 years. I prefer to remain invested instead of waiting around.
Good advice about re-evaluating rather than panicking. If you can't handle a 10% drawdown you probably need to re-evaluate your asset allocation. For me, it's just the first significant drawdown in terms of dollars rather than percentage I've been through, so it's time to step back and re-calibrate my thinking rather than change something with my portfolio.
|
|
|
Post by rgs2001uk on Nov 1, 2018 20:54:36 GMT 7
Depends where you are on lifes highway, the stockmarket probably isnt for widows and orphans.
I have never sold anything or cashed in, I might sell some stocks and reinvest in others.
Looking at my portfolio, its actually almost 33% higher in the last 10 years, taking into account the latest downturn.
Brunner and Bankers IT are still higher, Scottish Morg and Croda took at hit, but are still higher than what I paid for them.
Goes back to the age old question, what do you want, capital growth or regular income?
Actually at this moment I have about 10 grand in dividends stuck in a stockbroker account, what to buy, descions descions.
|
|
|
Post by rgs2001uk on Nov 1, 2018 21:27:46 GMT 7
|
|
AyG
Crazy Mango Extraordinaire
Posts: 5,871
Likes: 4,555
|
Post by AyG on Nov 2, 2018 7:23:57 GMT 7
Looking at my portfolio, its actually almost 33% higher in the last 10 years, taking into account the latest downturn. I'm struggling to make sense of that. Do you mean that it's peak value was 33% higher than now (i.e. it's fallen 25% from the peak)? Or do you mean it's gained only 33% over 10 years? Neither seems particularly likely.
|
|
|
Post by rgs2001uk on Nov 2, 2018 20:53:50 GMT 7
Looking at my portfolio, its actually almost 33% higher in the last 10 years, taking into account the latest downturn. I'm struggling to make sense of that. Do you mean that it's peak value was 33% higher than now (i.e. it's fallen 25% from the peak)? Or do you mean it's gained only 33% over 10 years? Neither seems particularly likely. Well spotted, I apologise for giving spurious data, looked at the wrong column without the reading glasses.
|
|
chiangmai
Crazy Mango Extraordinaire
Posts: 6,312
Likes: 5,334
|
Post by chiangmai on Dec 11, 2018 5:58:00 GMT 7
This thread was started in October and here we are in December and things are arguably much worse now than they were back then. When I think of a crash I think of a speeding train coming to an abrupt halt and then breaking into small pieces, the current picture more resembles a speeding train that is slowing with small pieces constantly falling off, the time scale is different but the end result is the same, a pile of small broken pieces.
On reflection I'm very pleased I got out of the market with my voluntary investments when I did, the decision to buy a UK flat and rent it out has more than compensated for any loss of income caused by a falling Pound. I'm also happy that some of my income is in USD because this has the same compensatory effect. And lastly, I'm super happy that I made the decision years ago to transfer funds into Thailand and accumulate Baht rather than Pounds or anything else, all that TVF nonsense about not transferring funds into Thailand and the safety of Thai banks is probably the worst piece of expat advice I've ever heard. As for the SIPP investments: I've taken Fletch's earlier advice and not done anything, in fact I rarely look, I'm not sure the old ticker would stand it!
|
|
FIREinTh
Crazy Mango
Posts: 85
Likes: 47
|
Post by FIREinTh on Dec 11, 2018 11:24:23 GMT 7
Thanks for sharing your situation. It sounds like you have a good plan and have benefited from some market timing. Even though the market is still going down, I keep looking back to August 2011. Back then, the market was also volatile and re-tested the original low 8 weeks later before going back up almost in a straight line and reaching new highs in March. As of right now, the S&P500 is only down about 13% from its all-time high, which for equities is nothing. It's at the same level it was at a year ago. It seems that even though the media is scaring us every day with a lot of negative news, there's really nothing wrong with the markets or economy. Maybe people including myself are so used to always seeing the market go up, including a recent year with no monthly drawdowns, that we over-react to even a bit of normal volatility. We have to remember it's the volatility and the risk of losing money that gives equities higher returns than government bonds. Now were are seeing that volatility for the first time in a long time. As for my situation, I put in a lump sum in November 2017. Overall, I'm down a bit since Europe and emerging markets have taken a larger hit than the US, but it's nothing to be concerned about. I do have some crypto and blockchain investments that are down though I maxed out my LTFs/RMFs in the beginning of the year, so my 2018 Thai investments have seen some losses, but again, the Thai market is only down about 11% from its all-time peak so it's nothing to worry about. The condo I'm buying was supposed to be ready now, but has been delayed until March. The buildings are finished and they're still working 24/7 so I'm not worried it getting finished. I don't mind the delay since it gives me more time to save money. The first half of 2019 I'll be putting all my savings towards my condo, then in the 2nd half maxing out LTFs/RMFs. In hindsight, I wish I had some cash to put into Europe and emerging markets right now, but I'm fully invested and tied up with the condo. On the other hand, I'm glad I invested the lump sum rather than averaging in because #1 it was easier, and #2 US markets were only lower than my entry point for a few weeks in the past year, and well above my entry point in January and May-Sept. In conclusion - don't worry about the short-term noise, don't listen to the media, and stick to your long-term plan.
|
|
chiangmai
Crazy Mango Extraordinaire
Posts: 6,312
Likes: 5,334
|
Post by chiangmai on Dec 13, 2018 6:40:59 GMT 7
For every looser there's a winner somewhere, one of them is Thailand....here's what Bloomberg has to say: - Thailand has posted current-account surpluses every month since the end of September 2014. As a percentage of gross domestic product, the third-quarter balance of 7.7 percent is among the highest in Asia and compares with Taiwan’s 13 percent. - Customs exports also posted gains every months but two in 2017 and 2018, supporting demand for the Thai currency. Despite some signs of a slowdown, the tourism sector remains a major driver. Exports of goods and services account for about two-thirds of Southeast Asia’s second-largest economy. - Foreign reserves are at about $203 billion, more than twice the amount the International Monetary Fund deems as adequate. - Speculation that the Bank of Thailand next week will deliver its first interest-rate increase since 2011 has also bolstered the baht; the central bank’s monetary policy committee discussed "conditions and appropriate timing to begin normalizing monetary policy in the future," according to the minutes of the Nov. 14 rate decision. - A combination of economic recovery and benign inflation was also supportive, with fund inflows to the bond market at $9.2 billion this year through Dec. 11. The finance ministry predicts economic growth of 4.5 percent for 2018, following 3.9 percent expansion in 2017. Inflation was 0.94 percent in November, with the commerce ministry saying a rate of about 1 percent is right for the economy.
So when expats in Thailand talk about investments, many seem to ignore the obvious currency investment that's right on their doorstep, after all, if you spend Baht you need to hold Baht. Instead most seem to prefer to continbue to hold Pounds or whatevers and are too afraid to trust the Baht of Thai banks, citing political uncertainty, fabricated numbers and the safety of the FDIC over the DPA.....it's absolutely crazy.
There's nothing new in the above that hasn't been repeated publically many many times over the past couple of years, trying to get expats/westerners to believe it however is a different matter entirely! www.bloomberg.com/asia
|
|
FIREinTh
Crazy Mango
Posts: 85
Likes: 47
|
Post by FIREinTh on Dec 13, 2018 20:56:19 GMT 7
|
|
|
Post by Fletchsmile on Dec 14, 2018 13:13:56 GMT 7
Yes, I think Thailand is a decent play to have some assets. I don't focus too much on the currency rate, as I hold a significant proportion of assets here and in THB. The Thai equity market has been a bit frustrating and disappointing this year. SET is down around 8%. Domestically it hasn't done much wrong, even the politics, and the likelihood of next year's election going reasonably OK. Unfortunately they've just got dragged down with other global and EM markets, somewhat indiscriminately in my view. Some key reasons for that: 1) As global risks increase for whatever reason, eg Brexit, Trump, China, people just take money out of "risk" assets. A narrow minded view to an extent unless you think it really is going to lead to global systemic damage. Narrow minded in my opinion as pockets of value like Thailand can actually diversify the risk 2) Situations often get made much worse than they are by the media. They often just want to make stories that sell and bad news sells better than good. I watch Bloomberg TV every day in the background while doing other things. It's often as though they pull anyone the minute they start talking positively on a subject the media are trying to make it negative. 3) Some of it is also ignorance. Investors, media etc, simply don't really have a good handle on Thailand today. They just have a stereotype image of days gone by and the financial crisis. One of the most annoying TV anchors with respect to EM and Thailand is Tom Keene on Bloomberg. The old geezer with the bow Thai. Generally, he can be quite entertaining sometimes, and obviously has some knowledge and a long history in markets. However he understands f*** all about Thailand. So often he mentions it and says things like will we get a repeat of 1997, is Thailand going to fall over again, contagion, domino effect blah blah blah If he actually bothered reading some of his colleagues intelligent articles on Bloomberg he'd realise Thailand is a very different place today. Articles like the ones above show that. Bloombers articles are generally quite good. The TV channel more variable in quality as they are often striving to "find a story", but Tom Keen is just plain annoying and on Thaland So all in all while Thailand has potential, unfortunately the market is "always right" even when you know its wrong I think it was Buffet coined the phrase of markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent, in terms of trying to fight it. In recent years we've had "don't fight the Fed" etc Rather than automatically seeing yourself as wrong when a trade/ investment doesn't work a better way to think of it sometimes is just you're on the wrong side at the market at that point in time. You could well have got it wrong of course, but it could be that everything you think is correct, just the much vaster market is moving in a different direction. Markets often overshoot as well as having timing differences to reality. So my view: Thailand looks good. When it picks up/ that value gets recognised is always hard to time and call. Best thing is just ride it all out and in the long run, reality and fundamentals win out long term if you look at annualised returns
|
|
AyG
Crazy Mango Extraordinaire
Posts: 5,871
Likes: 4,555
|
Post by AyG on Dec 14, 2018 16:34:27 GMT 7
The Thai equity market has been a bit frustrating and disappointing this year. SET is down around 8%. True. Down 8.16% according to Bloomberg. However, I'm pretty sure the SET is not a "total return" index, so things are a bit better than that. Probably down around 5% overall.
|
|